Bishop Schneider: “Convert” or “renounce the papacy”

Submitted by LocutusOP on Sat, 03/04/2017 - 23:49
Author: 

Dennis ,Ana Milan , Lynda ,  Caimbeul,  crusader,  Al The Silent,  my2cents , AlphonsusJr      

Date: 
Saturday, March 4, 2017 - 23:45
Article link: 
Bishop Schneider: “Convert” or “renounce the papacy”

 

 
  1. Dennis February 23, 2017

    I don’t see how anyone can hear his comments and think anything other than what you say, Mr. V. He speaks the truth in more boldness, it seems, with each interview. So how it is that he (and others) can do so and not be exiled or punished in other ways by the current regime? Cdl. Burke was being ill-treated some time before the dubia. What’s the difference?

  • Ana Milan February 23, 2017

    Possibly because Bishop Schneider is an Auxiliary Bishop from a relative outpost of the CC & not yet a Cardinal (which one day please God he will be) gives him more scope for speaking his mind in this forthright way. It is long past time that ‘niceness’ to this disrespectful occupant of the Papal Office was discarded. PF does not esteem the position he was questionably elevated to & has done untold damage to the historic view that the Vicar of Christ can only be judged by God. This held fast since VI in 1870 but now, given the completely inappropriate &, one might say, anti-Catholic disregard for such reverence given to this Office, PF has driven a great axe into the belief of Papal Infallibility. The disgraceful circus acts played out in front of him on the feast of the Chair of St. Peter is enough to turn anyone’s stomach. His denial to answer the Dubia & silence when Bishops use strong-armed tactics to force seminarians to comply with AL even if in doing so they commit sacrilege, says it all. He is, apparently, quite willing to see them leave the seminaries (worldwide) if they dare to question AL, yet as he signed that document he must own it & therefore must also be able to confirm what exactly he meant to bring about. If not, he displays his inability to uphold the True Faith & must be formally & publicly asked to resign.

 

 

 

 

Lynda February 23, 2017

 

The papacy is charged with the defence and proclamation of the objective, unchangeable Deposit of Faith given us by God’s Revelation and the Tradition of His Holy Church; and the governance of the Church for that purpose. A dictatorship is arbitrary and total control without objective valid authority.

...

 

 

  1. Caimbeul February 23, 2017

    “….or “Renounce the Papacy,”” indicates that Bishop Schneider believes that Francis is the Pope. He isn’t saying that Francis isn’t the Pope.

  • Lynda February 24, 2017

    He still holds the exterior office of the papacy, even though he may have been a heretic/apostate for a long time (and thus not joined to the soul of the Church). For a visible office, visible action must be taken by visible authority in the Church.

...

  1. crusader February 24, 2017

    If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, then it has to be a duck; if somebody acts like heretic, speaks like heretic, then you know what he is. Don’t cheat yourself with some sophisticated theories, the horrible TRUTH is much simpler.
    “But let your speech be yea, yea: no, no: but that which is over and above these, is of evil.”(Mt5:37)

  • Al The Silent Crusader February 24, 2017

    I agree with you. I would add that Francis further condemns himself by not only what he says, but what he has written and attempted to pass off as official doctrine/dogma. For those of us who have eyes to see, and a brain that can process thoughts in a critical, analytic manner, we know that Francis is a public, manifest heretic. But, I get it. I am only a mere layman- not a member of the Catholic clergy. As such I cannot make this pronouncement. But I digress…

 

...

 

 

  1. my2cents February 24, 2017

    Francis the Hubris could never renounce the papacy. He is having too much fun doing and saying anything he wants without fear of consequences. Actually I think he loves negative attention the best because it empowers him to be a loose cannon. God bless Bishop Schneider, but his words have no impact on this miserable “papacy”. We need an army of Bishop Schneiders to invade the Vatican with an eviction notice. 

  • AlphonsusJr February 25, 2017

    An army of Bp. Schneiders would be woefully insufficient. Bp. Schneider refuses to speak directly. He’s milquetoast. We need an army of Abp. Lefebvres.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Own comment: 

I can do little else than agree with my2cents, who writes:

Francis the Hubris could never renounce the papacy. He is having too much fun doing and saying anything he wants without fear of consequences.

He also seems to enjoy trying to send souls to hell and mocking the Catholic Church and the Holy Trinity far too much for a resignation to be plausible.